Normal Map Data II

Here is one interesting normal data idea I missed. It is taken from Christer Ericson in his blog:

One clever thing they do (as mentioned on these two slides) is to encode their normal maps so that you can feed either a DXT1 or DXT5 encoded normal map to a shader, and the shader doesn’t have to know. This is neat because it cuts down on shader permutations for very little shader cost. Their trick is for DXT1 to encode X in R and Y in G, with alpha set to 1. For DXT5 they encode X in alpha, Y in G, and set R to 1. Then in the shader, regardless of texture encoding format, they reconstruct the normal as X = R * alpha, Y = G, Z = Sqrt(1 - X^2 - Y^2).

A DXT5-encoded normal map has much better quality than a DXT1-encoded one, because the alpha component of DXT5 is 8 bits whereas the red component of DXT1 is just 5 bits, but more so because the alpha component of a DXT5 texture is compressed independently from the RGB components (the three of which are compressed dependently for both DXT1 and DXT5) so with DXT5 we avoid co-compression artifacts. Of course, the cost is that the DXT5 texture takes twice the memory of a DXT1 texture (plus, on the PS3, DXT1 has some other benefits over DXT5 that I don’t think I can talk about).